I did not title this blog to be sarcastic. I wanted to draw your attention to the severity of the consequences of Indian Premier League’s (IPL) actions that will cause the eventual demise of the beautiful game of cricket.
IPL, a brain child of Lalit Modi, is a new money making, entertaining (supposedly, depends on who you talk to) brand new version of cricket. As a cricket fan I like to follow and support all forms of cricket. But I do have reservations to support IPL. In my opinion it is a travelling circus for which I thanked Mr. Modi last year.
Here is my last year’s post.
“A day after India crashed out of T20 world cup, it’s time to look back and appreciate a few performances and analyze what could have been better. As an avid (Indian) cricket fan it is hard to be objective in the thought process after a gut wrenching loss to a team which is yet to win a major event in their long cricketing history.
The team fought hard to save the pain for a billion cricket fans but fell short by 3 runs. We all have one man to thank for what has transpired to be a tough series which ended with a bit of chin music. England bowlers would not have dared to bowl those short balls if Sehwag suited up for the game. Dhoni concurs, asked if injured opener Virender Sehwag’s absence had an impact on India’s performance, Dhoni said: “He is the sort of player you can’t really replace – we missed him. When he starts off the bowler is under pressure. He’s a great player to have in your side.”
Mr. Modi can take the lion’s share of credit for Sehwag’s absence and Zaheer Khan’s fifty percent presence in the lineup. He has single handedly destroyed the dreams of billion fans and will continue to do that in the future. His thirst for power and money is unquenchable. He created a circus to entertain his motives and called himself a commissioner.
I am not trying to blame an injury or two for the team’s loss. I am trying to come to terms with the fact that those two injuries happened while playing in games which don’t matter to anybody and are already forgotten. This loss will linger in our minds for a long time, and it is quite painful.
I would like to thank Mr. Modi for saving my time by eliminating India from the world cup. I am sure corporate India will send him a few bouquets and gifts as millions of fans won’t call in sick for work after watching a late night game.
Thank you Mr. Modi, keep your ego-centric and narcissistic ideas coming and save us some time.”
First let’s examine the pros of this league.
- A lot of young cricketers get a chance to showcase their skills and earn a living. Never before this was possible in Indian economy.
- It takes only three hours to get a result. This is good for all of us who are in it for instant gratification. Enjoy while it lasts.
- Opportunity to market the game outside the traditional venues.
- I tried to come up with more benefits, sorry they don’t exist.
Having established the pros of IPL, let’s take a look at the drawbacks. I am a cricket fan, would like to see all formats (Test, One-Day and T20) of the game flourish. There seems to be a conflict of interest between IPL, which uses the three hour T20 format, and other traditional versions of the game. Fundamentals on which the IPL is being built are going to ruin the One-Day and Five-Day versions of the game and will inevitably erode cricket’s rich fabric.
I think IPL will fail for the following reasons.
- IPL is going to fasten the demise of Indian domestic cricket, which is already lacking support. Australia produces more world class players because they have a strong domestic cricket structure. This could hurt Indian cricket’s sustainability at international level.
- IPL franchise owners need to start making money sooner to get most out of their 10 year contract. This could be quite difficult in the short-term. According to some analyses, team owners may start getting some of their money back only after five years. Cricket Australia chief executive James Sutherland told Sydney radio station 2KY. “It’s nice to pay the players well and get big money from television rights and sponsorships, but ultimately you’ve got to provide a return for the owners.” Do you think the owners accept financial losses for five years and do nothing about it? I will get into the details of economics in a later post.
- Franchises may start taking decisions on players behalf (after all they bought the players at an auction), which could put them at loggerheads with BCCI.
- Revenue streams of Indian cricket may start running dry. Sahara group bought a franchise team spending 1700 crore Rupees (Approximately $378 million). According to Subrato Roy, Chairman of Sahara Group, they are emotionally attached to the game and now they are reconsidering their sponsorship deal with Team India because of their new purchase. Go figure.
- Too much cricket could reduce the length of a player’s career.
- Too much fatigue on players’ bodies hurts Indian cricket team’s performance at international level. Most of the fans remember India’s performance in 2009 edition of T20 world cup. Thanks to injuries sustained during 2009 IPL season, Sehwag and Zaheer were absent. Boy, did we feel their absence? We are already second guessing Dhoni and Gambhir’s chances of making it to 2010 T20 world cup.
Let’s hope the winning ways will be back again.
What do you think?

Posted by Sundeep 